The possibility that Elon Musk would be named to a key post if Donald Trump is elected in November sparked a reaction across the American media. As is often the case across the Atlantic, analyst reactions are as split and divided as the US is. The press also questions the coexistence between two very complex and divisive personalities.
If we are to summarize the point of view of the American media, four main trends emerge: optimism for innovation, concerns about governance, ideological compatibility, and finally the impact on the image of the United States in the world.
Major national media shared
Known for its editorial line largely favorable to Donald Trump, Fox News sees this possible nomination in a positive light. Analyst Kevin O’Leary expressed excitement about Elon Musk taking on a role in government, highlighting his leadership and innovation skills. Kevin O’Leary even goes so far as to consider Elon Musk a “modern day Bruce Wayne”. According to him, the head of Tesla and SpaceX will be able to provide effective solutions to government problems.
On the side New York Times and CNN is something else entirely. The newspaper New York takes a more critical position. The daily highlights concerns about the impact such an appointment could have on the separation of powers and the risks associated with the concentration of influence in the hands of such a powerful person in the private sector.
THE New York Times also raises the question of possible conflicts of interest because Elon Musk’s activities are clearly connected to government policy. CNN partially shares the analysis New York Times with particular emphasis on the potential implications for democracy and governance in the United States.
The local press is closest to the states’ interests
In the rest of the country, the local press reacted according to each state’s interests. Before Los Angeles Timesis the appointment of Elon Musk worrying. According to the newspaper, Elon Musk would risk gaining disproportionate power if he joined the administration. Editors wonder if he could use this position to serve his own interests rather than the public interest.
In Texas is Houston Chronicle acknowledges the risk of such an appointment. But the daily assesses that Elon Musk could also bring the expected wind of change. According to the newspaper, his innovative spirit and non-conformist approach could shake up the political establishment and unlock new solutions. However Houston Chronicle also emphasizes the need to preserve democratic balances and separation of powers.
All about the 2024 US presidential election
Overall, the American press, of all stripes, seems rather worried about the implications of this possible appointment. Although few analysts are concerned about the economic consequences, they almost unanimously raise the risks to the balance of power and the integrity of institutions.